Thorogood Men’s American Heritage 6″ Safety Toe Boot Review

By tim / March 5, 2017
Thorogood Men’s American Heritage 6″ Safety Toe Boot

If you are searching for a comfortable, modern and durable pair of leather boots, the choices offered by Thorogood will probably delight you. Manufactured by the Weinbrenner Shoe Company, Thorogood has been among the most iconic footwear brands in America, carrying a proud history of rolling out innovative and top quality products since 1892. Over the last decade, one of the top selling work boots from the brand has been the Thorogood Men’s American Heritage 6’’ Safety Toe Boot.


  • High-comfort polyurethane sole
  • Superior abrasion-resistant oil-tanned leather front
  • Comfortable shock resistant foot-bed
  • Durable sole design with Goodyear Welt construction
  • Slightly overpriced when compared to competitors
  • Only one color option
  • Not waterproof

Key Features

  • Slip resistant sole design
  • Steel toe front with ample foot space
  • Ventilated insole
  • Available in black walnut color
  • Manufactured in America
  • Cowhide leather exterior
  • Option to return for size and color preferences

What is the Thorogood Men’s American Heritage 6’’ Safety Toe Boot?

The Thorogood Men’s American Heritage 6’’ Safety Toe Boot is a leather boot primarily designed for usage in industrial/construction and rugged outdoor conditions.

It’s a middle of the line Wellington style safety toe boot and boasts a durable Goodyear welt construction. With ample consideration for safety and comfort factors in the everyday work environment, the boot will help just about any man be comfortable on his feet even in the most rugged environments.

Thorogood Men’s American Heritage 6’’ Safety Toe Boot Detailed Review

Here is the review of the different aspects of the Thorogood Men’s American Heritage 6’’ Safety Toe Boot. 

  • Design & Build Quality 7/5

This boot has been designed keep in mind the everyday demands of rough industrial or outdoor construction workers. In a nutshell, this boot stands out as a really good combination of safety, comfort and design. It sports a Wellington design and comes in a reddish-brown type Black Walnut oil tanned shade. Despite the single color option, it is incredibly compatible with a wide range of garment colors. The stitching appears flawless and mixes really well with the overall boot design.

  • Comfort 8/5

With a Dri-Lex fabric lining, the boots delivers utmost comfort by preventing the easy accumulation of sweat and moisture while it’s being worn. The boot feels comfortable even when it's used in different weather conditions, including cold and humid conditions. The removable cushion foot-bed and the soles feel very easy on the heels as well. Provided that you buy a boot of the right size, it’s highly unlikely that it will be uncomfortable to your feet, even if you wear it for several hours.

  • Durability 5/5

The boot has an excellent abrasion-resistance capabilities and the oil-tanned leather won’t discolor or wear out easily with normal everyday industrial work impacts. The shoe is Goodyear Welted, meaning that even if the soles wear out, you will be able to reuse the leather body for years to come. With regular polishes and oil tanning, the shoe will also keep retaining its look for many years.

  • Reliability 4.5/5

This boot does indeed seem to boast better slip-resistance features, especially when compared to the similarly priced safety boots from many competing brands. Above all, this boot can easily help you in navigating smooth or uneven terrains without much difficulty. The thick cowhide leather front won’t puncture easily, while the front area of the sole is also built to resist everyday abrasions in the industrial work environment.

  • Price 4.5/5

Considering the wide variety of features and the durability of these boots, it does indeed provide a good value for money. However, boots with similar features from competing brands like Wolverine and Timberland may appear to be somewhat cheaper. But, considering that Thorogood is a fully Made in America brand made by Union workers, it can indeed stand out as a better product compared to most Made in China boot.

Overall Score: 4.7/5

How Do They Compare?

Let’s take a look at some of the Thorogood Men's American Heritage 6" Safety Toe Boot’s competition:

Wolverine Men's W03120 Work Boot Priced somewhat lower that the American Heritage 6’’, this boot is also waterproof and includes handmade soles. But it does offer more color options and is available in two colors: brown and black. However, it’s made in China and doesn’t include a leather body that’s as strong as the American Heritage.

Amazon link

Timberland PRO Men's 26078 Titan 6" Waterproof Safety-Toe Work Boot

Slightly higher priced that the American Heritage 6’’ Safety Toe Boot, this includes some more features including a 30-day return policy. These boots come in dark mocha colors and are made in Vietnam

Amazon link

Caterpillar Men's Second Shift Steel Toe Work Boot Caterpillar are renowned for making some of the sturdiest work boots and this boot doesn’t disappoint in that regard. Despite being priced low, this boot is built to handle really tough work conditions. It also comes in two color variants. However, like the Wolverine W013120, it is also made in China.

Amazon link

Carhartt Men's CMF6366 6 Inch Composite Toe Boot This boot comes with extra stretching capabilities with which you can be able to get a very comfortable day in the work. However, it’s priced around a range that is similar to the American Heritage 6’’ despite the fact that this it is manufactured in China.

Amazon link

Should I buy the Thorogood Men’s American Heritage 6’’ Safety Toe Boot?

If you are looking for a safety toe boot that’s made in America and isn’t very high priced then this boot will be worth your money. However, that being said, there are a lot of boots with equivalent quality in the market and are priced somewhat lower. Yet, it cannot be denied that this is probably one of the best 6’’ Safety Toe Boots in the market, with durability and quality features that is second best to none.

About the author


    Click here to add a comment

    Leave a comment: